I found the bug.
.NET does the following in clr\src\vm\comnumber.cpp:
DoubleToNumber(value, DOUBLE_PRECISION, &number);
if (number.scale == (int) SCALE_NAN) {
gc.refRetVal = gc.numfmt->sNaN;
goto lExit;
}
if (number.scale == SCALE_INF) {
gc.refRetVal = (number.sign? gc.numfmt->sNegativeInfinity: gc.numfmt->sPositiveInfinity);
goto lExit;
}
NumberToDouble(&number, &dTest);
if (dTest == value) {
gc.refRetVal = NumberToString(&number, 'G', DOUBLE_PRECISION, gc.numfmt);
goto lExit;
}
DoubleToNumber(value, 17, &number);
DoubleToNumber is pretty simple — it just calls _ecvt, which is in the C runtime:
void DoubleToNumber(double value, int precision, NUMBER* number)
{
WRAPPER_CONTRACT
_ASSERTE(number != NULL);
number->precision = precision;
if (((FPDOUBLE*)&value)->exp == 0x7FF) {
number->scale = (((FPDOUBLE*)&value)->mantLo || ((FPDOUBLE*)&value)->mantHi) ? SCALE_NAN: SCALE_INF;
number->sign = ((FPDOUBLE*)&value)->sign;
number->digits[0] = 0;
}
else {
char* src = _ecvt(value, precision, &number->scale, &number->sign);
wchar* dst = number->digits;
if (*src != '0') {
while (*src) *dst++ = *src++;
}
*dst = 0;
}
}
It turns out that _ecvt returns the string 845512408225570.
Notice the trailing zero? It turns out that makes all the difference!
When the zero is present, the result actually parses back to 0.84551240822557006, which is your original number — so it compares equal, and hence only 15 digits are returned.
However, if I truncate the string at that zero to 84551240822557, then I get back 0.84551240822556994, which is not your original number, and hence it would return 17 digits.
Proof: run the following 64-bit code (most of which I extracted from the Microsoft Shared Source CLI 2.0) in your debugger and examine v at the end of main:
#include <stdlib.h>
#include <string.h>
#include <math.h>
#define min(a, b) (((a) < (b)) ? (a) : (b))
struct NUMBER {
int precision;
int scale;
int sign;
wchar_t digits[20 + 1];
NUMBER() : precision(0), scale(0), sign(0) {}
};
#define I64(x) x##LL
static const unsigned long long rgval64Power10[] = {
// powers of 10
/*1*/ I64(0xa000000000000000),
/*2*/ I64(0xc800000000000000),
/*3*/ I64(0xfa00000000000000),
/*4*/ I64(0x9c40000000000000),
/*5*/ I64(0xc350000000000000),
/*6*/ I64(0xf424000000000000),
/*7*/ I64(0x9896800000000000),
/*8*/ I64(0xbebc200000000000),
/*9*/ I64(0xee6b280000000000),
/*10*/ I64(0x9502f90000000000),
/*11*/ I64(0xba43b74000000000),
/*12*/ I64(0xe8d4a51000000000),
/*13*/ I64(0x9184e72a00000000),
/*14*/ I64(0xb5e620f480000000),
/*15*/ I64(0xe35fa931a0000000),
// powers of 0.1
/*1*/ I64(0xcccccccccccccccd),
/*2*/ I64(0xa3d70a3d70a3d70b),
/*3*/ I64(0x83126e978d4fdf3c),
/*4*/ I64(0xd1b71758e219652e),
/*5*/ I64(0xa7c5ac471b478425),
/*6*/ I64(0x8637bd05af6c69b7),
/*7*/ I64(0xd6bf94d5e57a42be),
/*8*/ I64(0xabcc77118461ceff),
/*9*/ I64(0x89705f4136b4a599),
/*10*/ I64(0xdbe6fecebdedd5c2),
/*11*/ I64(0xafebff0bcb24ab02),
/*12*/ I64(0x8cbccc096f5088cf),
/*13*/ I64(0xe12e13424bb40e18),
/*14*/ I64(0xb424dc35095cd813),
/*15*/ I64(0x901d7cf73ab0acdc),
};
static const signed char rgexp64Power10[] = {
// exponents for both powers of 10 and 0.1
/*1*/ 4,
/*2*/ 7,
/*3*/ 10,
/*4*/ 14,
/*5*/ 17,
/*6*/ 20,
/*7*/ 24,
/*8*/ 27,
/*9*/ 30,
/*10*/ 34,
/*11*/ 37,
/*12*/ 40,
/*13*/ 44,
/*14*/ 47,
/*15*/ 50,
};
static const unsigned long long rgval64Power10By16[] = {
// powers of 10^16
/*1*/ I64(0x8e1bc9bf04000000),
/*2*/ I64(0x9dc5ada82b70b59e),
/*3*/ I64(0xaf298d050e4395d6),
/*4*/ I64(0xc2781f49ffcfa6d4),
/*5*/ I64(0xd7e77a8f87daf7fa),
/*6*/ I64(0xefb3ab16c59b14a0),
/*7*/ I64(0x850fadc09923329c),
/*8*/ I64(0x93ba47c980e98cde),
/*9*/ I64(0xa402b9c5a8d3a6e6),
/*10*/ I64(0xb616a12b7fe617a8),
/*11*/ I64(0xca28a291859bbf90),
/*12*/ I64(0xe070f78d39275566),
/*13*/ I64(0xf92e0c3537826140),
/*14*/ I64(0x8a5296ffe33cc92c),
/*15*/ I64(0x9991a6f3d6bf1762),
/*16*/ I64(0xaa7eebfb9df9de8a),
/*17*/ I64(0xbd49d14aa79dbc7e),
/*18*/ I64(0xd226fc195c6a2f88),
/*19*/ I64(0xe950df20247c83f8),
/*20*/ I64(0x81842f29f2cce373),
/*21*/ I64(0x8fcac257558ee4e2),
// powers of 0.1^16
/*1*/ I64(0xe69594bec44de160),
/*2*/ I64(0xcfb11ead453994c3),
/*3*/ I64(0xbb127c53b17ec165),
/*4*/ I64(0xa87fea27a539e9b3),
/*5*/ I64(0x97c560ba6b0919b5),
/*6*/ I64(0x88b402f7fd7553ab),
/*7*/ I64(0xf64335bcf065d3a0),
/*8*/ I64(0xddd0467c64bce4c4),
/*9*/ I64(0xc7caba6e7c5382ed),
/*10*/ I64(0xb3f4e093db73a0b7),
/*11*/ I64(0xa21727db38cb0053),
/*12*/ I64(0x91ff83775423cc29),
/*13*/ I64(0x8380dea93da4bc82),
/*14*/ I64(0xece53cec4a314f00),
/*15*/ I64(0xd5605fcdcf32e217),
/*16*/ I64(0xc0314325637a1978),
/*17*/ I64(0xad1c8eab5ee43ba2),
/*18*/ I64(0x9becce62836ac5b0),
/*19*/ I64(0x8c71dcd9ba0b495c),
/*20*/ I64(0xfd00b89747823938),
/*21*/ I64(0xe3e27a444d8d991a),
};
static const signed short rgexp64Power10By16[] = {
// exponents for both powers of 10^16 and 0.1^16
/*1*/ 54,
/*2*/ 107,
/*3*/ 160,
/*4*/ 213,
/*5*/ 266,
/*6*/ 319,
/*7*/ 373,
/*8*/ 426,
/*9*/ 479,
/*10*/ 532,
/*11*/ 585,
/*12*/ 638,
/*13*/ 691,
/*14*/ 745,
/*15*/ 798,
/*16*/ 851,
/*17*/ 904,
/*18*/ 957,
/*19*/ 1010,
/*20*/ 1064,
/*21*/ 1117,
};
static unsigned DigitsToInt(wchar_t* p, int count)
{
wchar_t* end = p + count;
unsigned res = *p - '0';
for ( p = p + 1; p < end; p++) {
res = 10 * res + *p - '0';
}
return res;
}
#define Mul32x32To64(a, b) ((unsigned long long)((unsigned long)(a)) * (unsigned long long)((unsigned long)(b)))
static unsigned long long Mul64Lossy(unsigned long long a, unsigned long long b, int* pexp)
{
// it's ok to losse some precision here - Mul64 will be called
// at most twice during the conversion, so the error won't propagate
// to any of the 53 significant bits of the result
unsigned long long val = Mul32x32To64(a >> 32, b >> 32) +
(Mul32x32To64(a >> 32, b) >> 32) +
(Mul32x32To64(a, b >> 32) >> 32);
// normalize
if ((val & I64(0x8000000000000000)) == 0) { val <<= 1; *pexp -= 1; }
return val;
}
void NumberToDouble(NUMBER* number, double* value)
{
unsigned long long val;
int exp;
wchar_t* src = number->digits;
int remaining;
int total;
int count;
int scale;
int absscale;
int index;
total = (int)wcslen(src);
remaining = total;
// skip the leading zeros
while (*src == '0') {
remaining--;
src++;
}
if (remaining == 0) {
*value = 0;
goto done;
}
count = min(remaining, 9);
remaining -= count;
val = DigitsToInt(src, count);
if (remaining > 0) {
count = min(remaining, 9);
remaining -= count;
// get the denormalized power of 10
unsigned long mult = (unsigned long)(rgval64Power10[count-1] >> (64 - rgexp64Power10[count-1]));
val = Mul32x32To64(val, mult) + DigitsToInt(src+9, count);
}
scale = number->scale - (total - remaining);
absscale = abs(scale);
if (absscale >= 22 * 16) {
// overflow / underflow
*(unsigned long long*)value = (scale > 0) ? I64(0x7FF0000000000000) : 0;
goto done;
}
exp = 64;
// normalize the mantisa
if ((val & I64(0xFFFFFFFF00000000)) == 0) { val <<= 32; exp -= 32; }
if ((val & I64(0xFFFF000000000000)) == 0) { val <<= 16; exp -= 16; }
if ((val & I64(0xFF00000000000000)) == 0) { val <<= 8; exp -= 8; }
if ((val & I64(0xF000000000000000)) == 0) { val <<= 4; exp -= 4; }
if ((val & I64(0xC000000000000000)) == 0) { val <<= 2; exp -= 2; }
if ((val & I64(0x8000000000000000)) == 0) { val <<= 1; exp -= 1; }
index = absscale & 15;
if (index) {
int multexp = rgexp64Power10[index-1];
// the exponents are shared between the inverted and regular table
exp += (scale < 0) ? (-multexp + 1) : multexp;
unsigned long long multval = rgval64Power10[index + ((scale < 0) ? 15 : 0) - 1];
val = Mul64Lossy(val, multval, &exp);
}
index = absscale >> 4;
if (index) {
int multexp = rgexp64Power10By16[index-1];
// the exponents are shared between the inverted and regular table
exp += (scale < 0) ? (-multexp + 1) : multexp;
unsigned long long multval = rgval64Power10By16[index + ((scale < 0) ? 21 : 0) - 1];
val = Mul64Lossy(val, multval, &exp);
}
// round & scale down
if ((unsigned long)val & (1 << 10))
{
// IEEE round to even
unsigned long long tmp = val + ((1 << 10) - 1) + (((unsigned long)val >> 11) & 1);
if (tmp < val) {
// overflow
tmp = (tmp >> 1) | I64(0x8000000000000000);
exp += 1;
}
val = tmp;
}
val >>= 11;
exp += 0x3FE;
if (exp <= 0) {
if (exp <= -52) {
// underflow
val = 0;
}
else {
// denormalized
val >>= (-exp+1);
}
}
else
if (exp >= 0x7FF) {
// overflow
val = I64(0x7FF0000000000000);
}
else {
val = ((unsigned long long)exp << 52) + (val & I64(0x000FFFFFFFFFFFFF));
}
*(unsigned long long*)value = val;
done:
if (number->sign) *(unsigned long long*)value |= I64(0x8000000000000000);
}
int main()
{
NUMBER number;
number.precision = 15;
double v = 0.84551240822557006;
char *src = _ecvt(v, number.precision, &number.scale, &number.sign);
int truncate = 0; // change to 1 if you want to truncate
if (truncate)
{
while (*src && src[strlen(src) - 1] == '0')
{
src[strlen(src) - 1] = 0;
}
}
wchar_t* dst = number.digits;
if (*src != '0') {
while (*src) *dst++ = *src++;
}
*dst++ = 0;
NumberToDouble(&number, &v);
return 0;
}